The 3/5 Solution

Once again we see the shock and horror that a black man has been murdered in broad daylight by someone legally hired and empowered by the state. YAWN.

Once again we hear the calls for peace and tranquility. Calls for “law and order”. Calls for patience . The questioning of “How did we come to this?” YAWN

The US did not “come to this”. This is who we are. As a nation. Our holy and worshiped founding fathers made it clear in the Constitution. Black men and women are 3/5th of a person. It was true then, it is true now.

Article 1, section 2 … Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons

Of course “all other persons” were the slaves. So the southern states could claim the black men, women and children were property. And then claim that those very same men , women and children must be counted as 3/5 of a person for purposes of representation in the House of Representatives.

So, at the outset of the Civil War almost 4,000,000 slaves added 2,400,000 “persons” to the total population of the slave states. Giving the slave states representation in Congress far beyond the actual number of “citizens”.

From day one black people in the United States have been considered less than “full” people. And that is the bare truth of the foundations of this nation. Like it or not.

So, when the KKK brutalized black Americans after the racists lost the Civil War, it should come as no surprise. And when Jim Crow kept blacks from getting uppity in the south, that should come as no surprise. And when black soldiers returning from WW2 were refused service at restaurants and denied the right to vote, that should come as no surprise.

What should be surprising is the strength of the myth. The myth that the US was founded on principles of freedom, democracy, blah,blah,blah. That has never been and never was the reality. It was and is “fake news”.

Now, you may say, but what about the Voting Rights Act and other Civil Rights acts? Don’t they show progress? To that I respond thusly.

If the US was founded and grew on principles of equality, why was there a need for a Voting Rights Act? Or special Civil Rights acts? Why did we need special laws for black men and women just to try to give them the same rights the rest of society enjoys? In the “land of the free” why was it necessary to write special laws giving “freedom” to citizens who should have already had it?

And, as we have seen, the Supreme Court has overturned even those laws. Since the Voting Rights Act was rescinded how many states immediately took steps to suppress and deny votes to black citizens? How many blacks were purged illegally from the voting rolls in Florida in 2000, giving the election to GW Bush? How many were purged in North Carolina and Georgia in 2016?

But the myth lives on. It is a nice myth. A comfortable myth. A myth that tries to place the suppression and murder of black Americans in a certain context. That context is this: The murder and suppression of blacks in the US is an aberration. A blip on the screen of democracy. A pimple on the otherwise perfect face of equality.

I disagree. Racism has been at the core of the American experience. The very core of the legal system. It is as old as the US Constitution and may never be erased. Racism is as American as violence. Both go hand in hand.

It is not just the south. In the north as well racism is a core value. Highways were built around cities effectively cutting off black neighborhoods from white ones. The attempt at segregation was halted by the practices of the banking industry. Schools in NY, for example, are among the most highly segregated in the nation.

So, let’s stop pretending. The 3/5 solution is still with us. Black men and women are not valued unless they can sing or bounce a basketball. Racism is not a southern phenomenon or an aberration. It is what America was founded on.

Is there a “solution”? There can be no solution when those in power do not see a problem. Or identify the problem as a “black” problem. Just another example of “uppity” Negroes not knowing their place. It has always been thus in America and I suspect may always be so.

I know if I were a black person in America I would go nowhere without being armed. I would suspect every police officer of being a potential killer. I would shoot first and ask questions later. I would know, not just claim, that my life is in danger every day. In fact, I remain amazed at the patience and willingness of most black Americans to work “within the system” when the system is so obviously corrupt. I would not have that patience.

Is there a “solution’? Not until we confront and destroy the myth. The myth of the “founding fathers” and the myth of “democracy” and the myth of “equal justice under the law”.

People die easy. A bullet . A knee to the neck. A chokehold. Myths are not so easy to kill. The 3/5 solution is on display every day.

8 Comments

Filed under african-american, blacks, choke hold, civil war, Congress, crime, Education, government, North Carolina, police, police brutality, Politics, racism, SCOTUS, Secession, slavery, Society, Supreme Court, United States, violence

8 responses to “The 3/5 Solution

  1. When I wrote the first of my two posts prompted by the George Floyd murder, I was lamenting how few white people were demonstrating. That was early on. The millions of people were enormously diverse and included large numbers of young white people. (I fervently hope there isn’t a huge spike in Covid-19 as a result.)
    My point is that though we seem to have to relearn these hard lessons, I believe/hope that the coming generations will demand social change and may well advance the arc of justice. The big question short term, as Obama hinted at today, is whether they’ll realize that demonstrating and voting are both necessary for social change. Those kids just gotta get to the polls this November!

    Like

  2. You are so brutally spot on! We don’t want to see it, don’t want to admit it, but you are right … racism isn’t anything new … it’s been around since before the Founding Fathers drafted the Constitution. That it seems worse today is largely because of the magnifying glass of social media, and because since the Civil Rights movement in the 1960s, we have kidded ourselves, told ourselves that the problems were fixed. Sigh.

    Like

  3. whungerford

    No one thought that a slave was 3/5 of a person. Southerners wanted to count them 100% as persons only for determining representation in Congress. Northerners didn’t want to count them at all for the same reason. Without the 3/5 compromise, there might be more countries in North America then there are today. Those counted as 3/5 of a person weren’t represented or consulted, and their social status never affected the compromise.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Of course not. To the slave states a slave was mere property. To northern abolitionists, including Lincoln, they were people. How much better off we would all be if , in fact, the union never included the slave states!

      Like

  4. maryplumbago

    Also do you mind if I share your post to another blog of like minded people?

    Liked by 1 person

  5. maryplumbago

    Spot on! Excellent post!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. EXTREMELY well said. Racism will never be eradicated so long as there are racist and easily (mis)led human beings….but we can and must reverse course by electing better leaders with the empathy and resolve to take us where we need to go as a nation, morally and ethically.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s